Optimizing Feature Selection with Variance Thresholding Techniques
Written on
Introduction to Feature Selection Using Variance Thresholding
In today's data landscape, it is not uncommon to encounter datasets boasting hundreds or even thousands of features. While this may initially appear beneficial—providing more insights into each sample—many of these additional features often contribute little value and complicate the analysis unnecessarily.
The primary objective in Machine Learning is to construct models that possess strong predictive capabilities, utilizing the minimum number of features necessary. However, with the sheer volume of features in modern datasets, it can be challenging to identify which ones are truly significant.
This brings us to a crucial aspect of Machine Learning: feature selection. This process involves selecting the most relevant features while preserving as much information as possible. For instance, consider a dataset containing body metrics such as weight and height. Basic feature selection might eliminate BMI, as it can be derived from weight and height.
In this article, we will delve into a specific feature selection method known as Variance Thresholding. This straightforward and efficient technique allows for the removal of features that exhibit low variance, meaning they do not provide much valuable information.
Understanding Variance
Variance, in essence, indicates the degree of variability within a dataset. It quantifies how spread out the distribution is, measuring the average squared deviation from the mean. Generally, a distribution with larger values will yield a higher variance. However, in the context of Machine Learning, we are primarily interested in whether a distribution conveys useful information.
For example, a distribution with zero variance is entirely uninformative. Utilizing a feature with zero variance complicates the model without enhancing its predictive abilities. Similarly, features that cluster around a single constant value are also of little use; thus, any feature with negligible variance should be discarded.
Employing Scikit-learn's VarianceThreshold Estimator
Calculating variances and applying thresholds manually can be labor-intensive. Fortunately, Scikit-learn offers the VarianceThreshold estimator, which automates this process. By simply specifying a threshold, any features below that value will be eliminated.
To illustrate the VarianceThreshold in action, we will utilize the Ansur dataset, which captures a wide array of human body measurements. This dataset includes 108 features from nearly 6000 individuals (4000 males and 2000 females) in the US Army, and we will focus on the male dataset.
First, we will eliminate features with zero variance by importing VarianceThreshold from sklearn.feature_selection. We initialize it like any other Scikit-learn estimator, where the default threshold is set to zero. As the estimator only functions with numeric data, an error will be raised if categorical features are present. Hence, we will extract the numeric features into a separate DataFrame.
After isolating 98 numeric features, we can fit the estimator and observe its results. Calling fit_transform will yield the DataFrame as a numpy array with the dropped features. If we prefer to retain the column names, we can use the get_support() method to generate a boolean mask indicating which columns are retained. This allows us to subset our DataFrame accordingly.
After checking the shape of our DataFrame, we see that the number of features remains unchanged. Now, let's apply a threshold to eliminate features with variances close to zero. With a threshold of 1, we successfully dropped one feature.
A Fairer Comparison of Variance Through Feature Normalization
It is often inequitable to compare the variance of one feature against another, as the variance tends to increase with larger values. To remedy this, we can normalize the features by dividing each by its mean, ensuring that all variances are comparable.
With normalized data, we can apply a lower threshold, such as 0.005 or 0.003, resulting in the removal of 50 features from the dataset. To evaluate the impact of this reduction, we will train two RandomForestRegressor models to predict an individual's weight in pounds: one on the optimized dataset and another on the complete numeric dataset.
Both models demonstrate high performance without overfitting, indicating that even after dropping 50 features, we have constructed a robust model.
Conclusion
While Variance Thresholding is a straightforward technique, it can significantly enhance feature selection. However, it is essential to remember that this method does not account for the relationships between features or their connection to the target variable. Therefore, it is advisable to verify that using this technique either improves performance or reduces model complexity, as demonstrated with the RandomForestRegressor.
For additional insights, refer to the official Scikit-learn user guide on feature selection, which provides instructions on incorporating VarianceThreshold estimators into pipeline instances, along with information on various other feature selection methods.
This first video tutorial covers the process of feature selection using variance thresholds to eliminate constant features, enhancing your understanding of practical applications in data science.
The second video provides an in-depth explanation of feature selection using variance thresholds, helping to solidify your grasp of this essential technique in machine learning.