Why Google's Hiring Practices Favor Cognitive Skills Over Grades
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding Google's Hiring Philosophy
Laszlo Bock, a previous executive at Google, highlights a significant insight regarding the hiring practices at the tech giant. He argues that high-achieving students from prestigious institutions often lack the intellectual humility that arises from experiencing setbacks. This can lead to an overly self-centered perspective.
"In their minds, if they succeed, it’s due to their brilliance; if they fail, it's attributed to others' incompetence or insufficient resources," Bock noted. Such a mindset clashes with Google's emphasis on continuous learning and the value of soft skills. Moreover, academic performance isn't the sole factor in Google's hiring decisions.
To illustrate this, Google once conducted a study revealing no significant link between an employee's performance and their GPA. This finding prompted a shift in their recruitment strategy. While the company once favored graduates from elite schools like Harvard and MIT, by 2018, they eliminated the degree requirement altogether.
Bock elaborated, "While good grades can be beneficial, the primary trait we seek in candidates is their general cognitive ability—not merely their IQ. It's about their capacity to learn and adapt quickly."
Section 1.1: The Qualities of an Ideal Google Employee
During his discussion, Bock mentioned several desirable traits that characterize a successful Googler, such as leadership and analytical skills. Remarkably, these attributes aren't necessarily linked to academic performance. However, Bock's remarks took a surprising turn when he addressed the perception of certain degrees.
Subsection 1.1.1: The Value of STEM vs. Humanities
Bock indicated that not all degrees are viewed equally by Google; humanities degrees, in particular, tend to be undervalued. He recounted a situation where a student contemplated switching from computer science to economics. Bock advised that it would be more advantageous for the student to remain a B student in computer science than to excel in humanities. "A stronger performance in a challenging field demonstrates resilience and critical thinking," he explained.
This perspective reflects a broader trend in how Google and the tech industry regard educational qualifications. Bock cited another example where a student shifted from electrical engineering to psychology, which he viewed as a misstep, as it would diminish the student's competitiveness in the job market.
Section 1.2: The Shift in Educational Focus
The notion that humanities education is less valuable has been prevalent, especially since the industrial revolution. Over the past three decades, degrees in computer science and engineering have become synonymous with career success. However, the connection between STEM fields and the tech industry is largely coincidental. Historically, universities aimed to cultivate well-rounded individuals, fostering intellectual growth rather than training for the workforce.
Humanities play a crucial role in this educational mission. For instance, understanding complex literature can be just as challenging as mastering programming languages.
Chapter 2: The Debate on Humanities in Tech
The undervaluation of humanities came into sharper focus when Naval Ravikant, a prominent Silicon Valley investor, dismissed these fields as "not a real science" during an appearance on Joe Rogan's podcast. He claimed that social sciences merely benefit from the credibility of more empirical disciplines like mathematics and physics, viewing humanities as politically motivated.
As someone who straddles both writing and technology, I find such an extreme viewpoint troubling. Both literature and technology require a blend of creativity and technical skill, and separating these elements can lead to subpar outcomes.
Currently, Silicon Valley seems to prioritize STEM disciplines, often at the expense of those with humanities backgrounds. So, while you may be tempted to submit your application, be aware that certain majors, like English, might not receive the same attention.
This video titled "Why was this Bay Area HS grad Google hire denied by 16 colleges?" delves into the struggles faced by candidates in the competitive landscape of college admissions and tech employment.
In another video, "High school grad rejected by 16 colleges reveals how he got Google job," the featured graduate shares insights on navigating rejection and ultimately finding success at Google.