# Let's Stop the Anti-Mask Jokes: They Harm Both Sides of the Debate
Written on
Understanding the Impact of Anti-Mask Humor
The internet is currently overflowing with self-righteous jokes targeting anti-mask proponents and those who dismiss scientific evidence, and frankly, it’s quite disheartening. Personally, I’m vaccinated and recall the early days of COVID when I spent countless hours advocating for mask-wearing among customers and employees, only to eventually close my coffee shop late last year.
I comprehend the humor in these jokes, as well as the schadenfreude that comes with witnessing anti-maskers contract COVID and find themselves in the ICU. The anger and disbelief that medical professionals must feel when they encounter these individuals in their hospitals is entirely understandable.
In our society, we benefit from certain privileges, so to me, resisting the vaccine is irresponsible, and rejecting masks is, to put it mildly, unwise. However, while venting our frustrations through humor may feel justified, mocking anti-maskers is ultimately counterproductive.
The Core Message Behind Anti-Mask Jokes
The fundamental message conveyed through jokes about anti-maskers is essentially “we are informed, and you are not.” This sentiment only serves to deepen the sense of persecution felt by the right-wing in America, who often feel marginalized by the so-called intellectual elite. Consequently, these memes and quips merely reinforce existing beliefs rather than encouraging dialogue.
Moreover, there is a deeper reason to reconsider this type of humor: it’s not just unhelpful; it can be detrimental to our own understanding as well.
Consider this cartoon, for instance:
The creator of this piece is unknown to me, as I stumbled upon it on iFunny. The humor is apparent; there are undoubtedly people out there who jump to conclusions. We have all made such assumptions at some point.
However, therein lies my argument. Scientists and medical professionals can and do miss critical information; it’s an inherent aspect of the scientific method. While the humor may seem innocent, comics like this imply that leading scientists and doctors are infallible, which we know is far from the truth.
Historical Missteps in Science
History is rife with instances where medical professionals and scientists have significantly erred. For instance, the drug Vioxx, prescribed by doctors, led to 60,000 fatalities before being removed from the market in 2004. The current opioid epidemic is also partly attributable to medical professionals alongside entities like the Sacklers and Johnson & Johnson.
We only reached a scientific consensus on human-caused climate change in the late 20th century or beyond. Numerous examples, both past and present, illustrate that errors are an inherent part of science. From doctors who smoked to the historical persecution of Galileo, the evidence is abundant.
Mistakes in science and medicine occur for various reasons, including human error, lack of comprehensive information, specialization limitations, and conflicts of interest that may cloud judgment. These types of errors are ongoing today, some of which will soon come to light, while others remain under the radar.
Addressing the Fallacy of Scientific Certainty
Some might argue that I am falling into the trap of the “Science Was Wrong Before” fallacy. However, I am not disputing any major scientific consensus; I am not claiming the Earth is flat or denying climate change. What I am asserting is that errors are still being made in science and medicine, as well as in other disciplines. Acting as if we have all the answers is foolish.
While rejecting mask mandates may seem misguided, it serves to challenge our confidence in what we believe we know. The truth is, we don’t possess all the answers, nor will we ever, and our experts have repeatedly demonstrated their fallibility.
For this reason, we should refrain from disseminating overt and covert messages that our institutions are beyond reproach. They are not, and denying the existence of problems only breeds distrust.
Chapter 2 Title: A Look at the Culture Surrounding Masks
This video, titled "Mask On or Off: You're Both Wrong | Andrew Schulz", delves into the complexities of mask-wearing debates, highlighting the misunderstandings that fuel division.
The Role of Music in the Anti-Mask Movement
In another perspective, "Kid Rock's New Anti-Mask Anthem Is Horrendous", critiques the cultural responses to mask mandates and the implications of anti-mask messaging in popular music.
By examining these viewpoints, we can better understand the multifaceted nature of the mask debate and its impact on society.