The Invisible Danger: How Racism Affects Air Quality in Black Communities
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding Environmental Racism
Racism, though often unspoken, permeates various aspects of life in the United States, including the very air we inhale. The connection between air quality and the racial composition of neighborhoods is stark and rooted in history. To grasp the current situation, one must delve into the legacy of racial segregation and discriminatory practices that have long influenced community dynamics. Generations of redlining and biased lending have perpetuated segregated neighborhoods, enabling corporations to exploit Black communities for profit while compromising their health and well-being. Thus, racism acts as a silent yet destructive force, contaminating the air and environments of these communities without any overt acknowledgment.
For instance, Louisiana stands as a poignant example of this phenomenon, often referred to as a "sacrifice zone." A detailed report, "The Fight for Life in a Louisiana Fossil Fuel Sacrifice Zone," highlights the state's toxic history, beginning with the system of chattel slavery that significantly shaped its socio-economic landscape. The report notes that "The Chitimacha and Choctaw people inhabited the banks of the Mississippi for millennia before European colonizers violently seized their territory," subsequently establishing a harsh slavery-based economy to sustain plantation operations. This historical context is crucial to understanding the dramatic shifts that have occurred due to industrial development.
Louisiana became a hub for the oil industry with the establishment of one of the first productive oil wells in 1901, leading to the rapid proliferation of oil refineries. These facilities convert crude oil into various petroleum products and release compounds like ethane, propane, and methane, used in manufacturing everyday items such as plastics and fertilizers. Consequently, the owners of these chemical plants have amassed considerable wealth, raising the question: at what cost?
Many of these plants, which emerged along the Mississippi River from the 1960s onward, bear the names of the plantations that once occupied the land. The region between Baton Rouge and New Orleans, once known as "Plantation Country," is now referred to as the "Petrochemical Corridor," a designation reflecting the proliferation of industrial facilities. Environmental scientists have also coined terms such as "Death Valley" and "Cancer Alley" to describe this area, emphasizing its hazardous reputation. Towns like Morrisonville, Reveilletown, and Sunrise, established by freed slaves, have been largely erased from history due to industrial encroachment.
Prior to the establishment of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in 1970, oil and gas companies in Louisiana operated without regulatory oversight. This lack of accountability allowed them to prioritize profits over the health of surrounding communities. Reports by organizations such as Human Rights Watch have called attention to the failures of government agencies, including the EPA and the Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality, to mitigate the harms inflicted by these industries. The consequences are dire, with rising incidences of cancer, maternal health issues, and respiratory illnesses reported in affected areas.
A pivotal 1987 article in the Washington Post first labeled this region as "Cancer Alley," highlighting the severe health crisis linked to fossil fuel and petrochemical operations. The piece recounted troubling incidents, such as workers experiencing nausea and headaches from toxic emissions near Baton Rouge. Despite persistent complaints from Black residents, effective governmental action to address the pollution has been largely absent. This is not mere oversight; it reflects a deliberate pattern of environmental racism in Louisiana.
The toxic legacy persists today. In a region where cancer rates are already alarmingly high—fifty times the national average—proposals for new petrochemical complexes continue to surface. Developers are even planning to construct these facilities atop grounds where enslaved individuals are likely buried. This blatant disregard for history and community well-being is exemplified by Formosa Plastics, a Taiwanese company pursuing the controversial Sunshine Project. Despite local resistance, the historical context of environmental racism suggests that these communities face an uphill battle.
Many Black residents of Louisiana view their surroundings as a "Fossil Fuel Sacrifice Zone," enduring elevated levels of pollution and hazardous materials that jeopardize their health. While tourists flock to New Orleans for festivities, the nearby towns suffer from air quality degradation due to industrial emissions, disproportionately affecting Black populations. Personal connections to this plight are evident, as friends and family reside within Cancer Alley, often unaware of the risks associated with living in such proximity to chemical plants.
The 2022 United Nations report on human rights and the environment highlighted Louisiana's Cancer Alley as a "sacrifice zone," illustrating severe human rights violations. The report emphasized that the existence of such zones reflects a failure to uphold the right to a clean and healthy environment, a stain on our collective conscience.
In a letter from the EPA, the agency condemned the environmental racism in Cancer Alley, accusing state regulators of neglecting the concerns of Black residents regarding toxic air pollution. A ProPublica investigation revealed that certain areas within Cancer Alley face a lifetime cancer risk up to 47 times higher than the EPA's acceptable threshold. Despite these alarming findings, state actions appear to hinder progress.
Federal efforts to enforce civil rights legislation aimed at protecting Black citizens from environmental hazards have been obstructed by local judicial decisions. Judge James D. Cain Jr.'s ruling halted the EPA and Department of Justice's attempts to address these injustices, highlighting the complex interplay of regulatory challenges.
According to the CDC, six common air pollutants—including carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxides—pose significant risks, particularly to Black communities that face higher concentrations of PM 2.5 and other toxins. The proximity of chemical plants along the Mississippi exacerbates these dangers, with local populations often left out of decision-making processes regarding industrial developments. The ethical implications are clear: exposing Black individuals to harmful chemicals without their consent is tantamount to conducting experiments on unknowing participants.
As Sharon Lavigne, a resident of St. James Parish, poignantly articulated, "We're dying from inhaling the industries' pollution. I feel like it's a death sentence. Like we are getting cremated, but not getting burnt." In Louisiana, the threat of environmental racism remains an insidious and lethal force.
Chapter 2: The Path Forward
The struggle against environmental racism is a continuous battle, requiring community resilience and advocacy. Residents of affected areas are mobilizing to demand accountability and change, but the road ahead is fraught with challenges. Only through collective action and awareness can the cycle of exploitation be broken.