The Case for Keeping Cameras Off in Remote Meetings
Written on
Chapter 1: The Debate Over Camera Use
For years, a persistent debate has existed within my workplace regarding the necessity of keeping cameras on during meetings. After much deliberation, it seems that my employer has emerged as the victor, while the majority of employees may not see it that way. This is a rare occurrence; often, both parties tend to be in the wrong.
Post-Pandemic Hybrid Work Environment
My employer implemented a hybrid work model after the pandemic, allowing employees to work from home part-time. Unfortunately, they did not invest in essential tools like monitors or ergonomic chairs to ease this transition. Despite various complaints highlighted by The Secret Developer, our experiences with blending in-person and virtual work have been quite revealing — if by revealing, we mean disastrous.
Segregated Team Events
Our attempts to engage remote and in-office team members during events have often fallen flat. Allow me to illustrate: We organized an activity that required participants to line up according to height. We had two groups — one in the office and one working from home. The result? The in-office team stood in silence for an excruciatingly long time before finally lining up, all while avoiding eye contact.
To be frank, the entire experience felt humiliating. However, I find myself feeling more embarrassed for the offshore team working from home. The expectation was to have cameras on, a guideline that most choose to ignore. One particularly resourceful Java developer justified their decision not to turn on their camera by keeping their laptop closed, claiming they wouldn’t open it for a single meeting. I can’t help but respect that stance.
To truly make our team-building event successful, we needed everyone’s cameras on. It’s disheartening to admit that there are colleagues I interact with daily but wouldn’t recognize on the street. This was our chance to connect. Alas, they wouldn’t even turn on their cameras for a moment, resulting in minimal conversation.
Research Findings
You might assume that scholars have extensively researched this topic, especially in the wake of 2020. Fortunately, they have! Their findings align with what many developers believe: keeping cameras off promotes happiness.
To spare you the need to dive into the entire study or even the accompanying HBR article, let me summarize: keeping cameras on is draining, exhausting, and ultimately unproductive. Surprisingly, there was no effort to engage employees in these discussions, as if our opinions didn’t matter.
For further reading, check out this source on the topic:
Conclusion
In conclusion, keeping your camera off can contribute to maintaining your sanity. Personally, I find that I often continue coding during meetings, and trust me, no one needs to witness the intense concentration that requires.
About the Author
Professional Software Developer “The Secret Developer” can be found on Twitter @TheSDeveloper and regularly publishes articles through Medium.com.
Chapter 2: The Impact of Camera Use on Remote Meetings
The first video title is "5 Reasons Why Turning Off Your Camera Leads To Better Meetings - YouTube." This video explores how keeping cameras off can foster a more productive meeting environment, allowing team members to focus on the content rather than their appearance.
The second video title is "Remote Work Rants: Should You Turn Your Camera On for Every Meeting? - YouTube." In this video, various perspectives on the necessity of camera use in remote meetings are discussed, providing insights into when it might be more beneficial to keep them off.